Updated: Aug 24
As a member of the Amazon Associates Affiliate program, I may earn a small commission for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial, and/or link to any products or services from this website at no extra cost to you. Your purchase helps support my work and allows me to continue creating content for you to enjoy.
If you've been following me recently, you know that I recently left my job as a teacher. This decision has led me to taking a much closer look at some of my habits and routines to see where I can pinch some pennies.
In all honesty, I didn't even drink coffee before I started teaching. I would order the occasional Starbucks drink for pure enjoyment but coffee was not a necessity in my life.
Then came student teaching. By the end of week two, I was drinking my coffee black and needed a second cup around lunch time to make it through the day. If you're not a teacher, you may not know that student teaching is a semester of working a full time job, except instead of getting paid, you are paying several thousand dollars for the opportunity. So once the milk and sugar ran out, I decided black coffee was fine with me.
Fast forward to today. The luxuries of working a full time job allowed me to build the habit of one to two K cups per day. Always with milk. Sometimes with sugar. These Starbucks Plus Blonde Roast are my K cup of choice and at $1.60 each, that's really not too frivolous!
But I also began to consider the waste. Our transition to a more frugal lifestyle has us researching vegetable garden beds and composting which has made me acutely aware of every item I throw in the garbage. Yes, I know that K cups are recyclable now. No, I do not take the time rip the lid off and clean them out in order to recycle them. I know. I know.
So, what you finally came here for. Here is how I make my delicious cold brew that feels like I'm splurging rather than scraping by! Rough calculation at the end.
1 cup of sugar
1 cup of water
My first step was to make a simple syrup. All you have to do is put 1 cup of water and 1 cup of sugar in a pot and bring it to a boil. Once it boils, take it off the heat and let it cool. I decided to make my syrup vanilla flavored only because I happened to have one vanilla bean left over from a previous recipe. At $8.99 for 2 vanilla beans, I would not have bought this item specifically for this recipe. I simply sliced the vanilla bean in half lengthwise and added it to the pot as soon as I took it off the heat. This recipe makes about (you guessed it) 1 cup of syrup. I used an old hot sauce bottle I saved, plus the jar the vanilla bean came it to keep the syrup stored tight in the fridge. I can't really tell you how much I put in my coffee because of the way the hot sauce bottle pours, but I would guess it's somewhere around 1/2 tablespoon. Could be a whole tablespoon on days I'm feeling saucy.
Now, to make the cold brew, you're going to need a pitcher or carafe with a tight fitting lid and a French press. You could definitely make this with a pour over and a filter but I've only read about it and haven't tried it because I don't have a pour over.
Step 1: Put 1 cup of coffee grounds and 3 cups of cold water in a pitcher or carafe with a tight fitting lid. Store this in the fridge for 12-24 hours.
Step 2: After 12-24 hours, filter the cold brew using a French press and pour into another container.
Because we are not spending any money, I have been using Justice's single serve French press and I have to pour my cold brew three times to get it all filtered. Honestly, it only takes about 3 minutes and I only have to do it every 3-4 days so it's fine for now.
Step 3: Add water to your coffee concentrate. With my first batch, I added the water after I poured my cup of coffee. After that I just started adding my water to the carafe. You want about 3/4 coffee concentrate and 1/4 cold water. You can adjust depending on how strong you want your coffee. Keep your cold brew in a the fridge with the lid tightly in place.
Step 4: Pour your cold brew over ice, add a dash of vanilla simple syrup, and top with your dairy of choice. (Whole cows milk in my house because I have a 2-year-old.)
This pitcher serves me 4 cups of coffee which lasts me 3-4 days depending on how much I drink.
Ok, so as far as calculating how much this costs, you need to understand that I was not a math teacher and several minutes of googling did not tell me how many ounces of coffee grounds make a cup so this is gonna be really rough. My calculations say that each glass of served coffee has $.15 of grounds, less than $.01 of sugar, and $.04 of milk. So there you have a 20 cent cup of coffee that taste like it's from a cafe.
Even better, if you have a reusable stainless steel straw and repurpose the coffee canister for storage or crafts when you're done, this is virtually waste free!
I hope you enjoy incorporating this affordable luxury into your coffee routine. Maybe just brew a batch on Friday evenings and enjoy cold brew all weekend. Happy caffeinating!